- 29/04/2019
- Posted by: Marta
- Categories: Questions and Answers, News
Dear Mr. Dongo,
I bought Chef cream at the supermarket "Light"Of Parmalat. The first question that arises spontaneously is why a product made in Italy indicates how "Milking country: milk from EU countries". The second question instead concerns the name "Light". Is it correct to indicate a cream in this way, is it not greasy anyway?
Many thanks
Rosalia
The lawyer Dario Dongo, Ph.D. in European food law, answers
Dear Rosalia good morning,
the label in question It does indeed present some not insignificant critical issues. First of all, the name of the food is missing. Reading the list of ingredients - which include 'modified starch, carob flour thickeners, carrageenan', after 'cream (97%) ' - in fact, it makes it possible to exclude that the food can be designated as'cream'.
The legal name food 'cream', or 'milk cream', is indeed reserved exclusively for dairy products only. (1) In this case a descriptive name must therefore be used, such as'condiment based on [or 'with'] cream (97%)'.
Il claim nutritional 'light' o 'light ', as provided for by the regulation 'Nutrition & Health Claims'(NHC, reg. EC 1924/06), can be used under the same conditions established for the indication 'at a reduced rate of [...]'. The requirements for the so-called claim comparative. (2) That is to say that:
a) the tenor of one or more nutrients must actually be reduced. To the extent of at least 30% (for macronutrients and / or energy value), or 10% for micronutrients, (e.g. vitamins and minerals), or 25% for sodium or salt, with respect to the term of comparison,
b) 'the comparison it can only be done between foods of the same category taking into account a range of foods of that category’,
c) the difference 'in the quantity of a nutrient and / or in the energy value'must be specified,
d) the nutritional element (be it nutrient / and / or energy value or micronutrient / or salt / sodium) that justifies the 'light' appellation must be specified. Ex. 'light in fat ', or 'light, x% less fat'.
Il claim comparative under examination is not correct, from two points of view:
- the comparison is made with a 'cooking cream' (whose name is in turn questionable, in the presence of additive 'carrageenan stabilizer'. In any case, the quantity of the highlighted ingredient should be specified). (3) Instead of with a product belonging to the same category ('condiment based on [or 'with'] cream (x%)'. (4)
- the comparison is made with the 'Chef's cooking cream. Which, evidently, cannot represent 'lon average of the best-selling products on the reference market', as instead prescribed by the Antitrust Authority (AGCM, so-called Antitrust), (5)
The indication 'gluten free' finally, it is incorrect, since it is a common feature of the condiments of the product category in question. Therefore, in this sense, a violation of the 'Food Information Regulation'. (6)
Cordially
Dario
Note
(1) See reg. UE 1308/13, cd 'Single CMO', article 78.1.c and Annex VII, Part III, paragraph 2.2.a.ii ('They are reserved for dairy products only:
(a) the following names used at all stages of marketing: (...)
ii) milk cream or cream'). Consolidated text on https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/IT/TXT/?qid=1556483216837&uri=CELEX%3A02013R1308-20190101, under review under the next European legislature (see article https://www.greatitalianfoodtrade.it/etichette/meat-sounding-il-parlamento-europeo-vota-contro)
(2) See reg. CE 1924/06 and subsequent amendments, Annex and article 9
(3) 'Stabilizer'and'thickener'? Regarding the criteria to be followed in determining the functional categories of food additives, see the previous article https://foodagriculturerequirements.com/archivio-notizie/domande-e-risposte/amido-modificato-o-addensante-e1442-sull-etichettatura-degli-additivi-la-parola-all-avvocato-dario-dongo
(4) On the concept of 'foodcategory', see paragraph 11.2.1 of the Guidelines 14.11.07 of the European Commission on the application of reg. CE 1924/06, on https://ec.europa.eu/food/sites/food/files/safety/docs/labelling_nutrition_claim_reg-2006-124_guidance_en.pdf. The Federalimentare Guidelines on 'Nutrition and Health Claims'- which the writer has previously drawn up together with other managers of the association system and are approved by the Ministry of Health - specify that the claim comparatives can only be performed between foods of the same category. As they share raw materials, manufacturing process and consumption opportunities. For this reason it is not considered admissible, for example, the nutritional comparison of a mortadella with an imitation made from poultry meat (v. https://foodagriculturerequirements.com/archivio-notizie/domande-e-risposte/mortadella-di-pollo-60-grassi-risponde-l-avvocato-dario-dongo)
(5) In this regard, see the cases of Pata and Amica Chips, examined by the AGCM in 2015, on https://www.greatitalianfoodtrade.it/consum-attori/antitrust-rassegna-alimentare
(6) See reg. EU 1169/11, article 7.1.c






