Artisan ice cream, still lacking a discipline. Two bills are presented to the Chamber

Artisan ice cream is a widely used definition, but lacks a legal definition. In Italy (and in Europe) there is no legislation on the subject yet. 

In the current legislature which should, except for early elections, be concluded by the spring of 2018, two bills have been presented to the Chamber, both by deputies of the M5S, of which examination has not yet begun. Therefore it is very unlikely that they will be transformed into a law of the Republic in a unified text.

Artisan ice cream and Europe

On 24 March 2017, the European Day of artisanal ice cream was celebrated in EU countries for the third time since its establishment. At present it is the only food product which has been awarded the attribution of a "Day".

On 5 July 2012 in Strasbourg, the European Parliament published its own Declaration on the establishment of the European Day of artisanal ice cream.

The Statement contains three preliminary considerations ("Recitals").

The first: European legislation is evolving in the direction of guaranteeing the quality of food products. Among fresh dairy products, artisanal ice cream represents excellence in terms of quality and food safety, which enhances the agro-food products of each individual Member State.

The second: consumer choices are increasingly oriented towards healthy, more nutritious, tastier foods obtained with traditional methods that do not affect the environment.

The third: the sector contributes to the direct employment, especially of young people, of about 300.000 workers in about 50.000 ice cream parlors throughout Europe. Furthermore, the consumption of ice cream is gradually becoming seasonally adjusted, thus creating a turnover of hundreds of millions of euros extended throughout the year.

An invitation to the Member States follows: support the quality production represented by artisanal ice cream as a sector of competitiveness for the European economy, which represents an opportunity to focus on given the current crisis affecting the dairy sector, among others.

The conclusion: the European Parliament establishes the European Day of artisanal ice cream, to be celebrated on 24 March, to contribute to the promotion of this product and to the development of the gastronomic tradition of this sector.

Artisanal ice cream in the legislation of Regions and Autonomous Provinces

The only legislation approved in Italy at the local level is the decree n. 27 of 19 May 2009 of the Autonomous Province of Bolzano. The provision dictates stringent rules for the use of the denomination "artisan ice cream". Based on a recall from the European Commission, the decree was withdrawn.

None of the Italian Regions, on the other hand, has so far equipped itself with a discipline on the subject.

In any case, a recent bill presented on February 19, 2017 by the regional councilor of the Casa delle Libertà, Francesco Cannizzaro for "The protection and enhancement of Calabrian artisan ice cream" should be noted.

The purposes of the initiative are indicated in Article 1: "The Calabria Region intends to protect the entire category of artisanal ice cream producers in the Calabrian territory, enhance the product through actions that enhance its uniqueness and territorial dominant characteristics, and activate the synergies necessary for the greater diffusion of Calabrian artisan ice cream in Italy and in the world".

The proposals for parliamentary initiative

The 4181, entitled "Provisions concerning the production of high quality artisanal ice cream”, Was presented on 21 December 2016 by L'Abbate (M5S) and others. The provision was announced on 3 March and assigned at the same time to the Agriculture Commission in the referent, with the opinions of the Constitutional Affairs, Justice, Budget, Productive Activities, Social Affairs, European Union policies and the bicameral Commission for regional issues.

The bill consists of six articles.

Article 1 Purpose. The aim is to offer both the consumer a tool for checking this food product and the true artisans of ice cream another means of enhancing the high quality of the product itself, in compliance with European Union legislation.

Article 2 Definition and requirements of high quality artisanal ice cream. High quality artisanal ice cream means a food preparation brought to a solid and pasty state by mixing and simultaneously freezing all the ingredients used.

The basic blend is produced with fat and proteins coming exclusively from fresh milk and chicken eggs, in shell or pasteurized, without the addition of flavorings, dyes and additives.

The artisanal ice cream is characterized, among other things, by the prevalent use of fresh and genuine raw materials. In the preparation of high quality artisanal ice cream, the use of semi-finished products in quantities not exceeding 10 percent of the total mixture and in any case not containing flavorings, dyes and additives, with the exception of natural flavors referred to in Regulation (EC) No. . 1334/20081.

Article 3: Preparation of high quality artisanal ice cream. In the preparation of high quality artisanal ice cream, manual skills must prevail over technological intervention. Furthermore, the ice cream must be whipped according to a discontinuous process, even with manual interventions.

Forced insufflation of air is forbidden, except for that naturally incorporated by freezing.

Any product that maintains the structure and consistency of ice cream at a temperature above 0 degrees C. It cannot be considered high quality artisan ice cream.

For the formulation of the various recipes, the high-quality fruit-based artisanal ice cream is characterized by a high content of fruit, sugars and possibly water. To obtain a finished product of optimal quality, it is necessary to use at least 10 percent by weight of citrus fruit or 30 percent by weight of other fresh or frozen fruit.

Again: the high-quality milk-based artisanal ice cream is characterized by the use of fresh milk and its fresh derivatives in a measure of no less than 70 percent by weight, with a combination of raw materials according to the creative flair of the ice cream maker and possibly, in the preparation of the mixture, of chicken eggs.

In the case of egg cream ice cream, the minimum percentage of egg yolk required in the recipe and used must be at least 6 percent by weight. In the case of cream ice cream, the minimum percentage of cream provided in the recipe and used must be at least eight percent by weight.

Article 4: Other ingredients. In the preparation of high quality artisanal ice cream, to obtain the finished product in different flavors and presentations, the use of finished food products that can be used for direct human consumption is allowed, such as biscuits, even in fragments, nougat, candied fruit, cocoa and derivatives, pods e buns and other cereal products. The products and any other ingredient used in the preparation or accompaniment of high quality artisanal ice cream may contain fats of animal or vegetable origin, except for hydrogenated fats and the following oils: palm oil, palm kernel oil, coconut oil and coconut oil. rapeseed.

The aromatic artisan ice cream is characterized only by the aromatic contribution of herbs, roots or berries, used in their entirety with the exclusion of extracts, which are separated from the mixture before freezing, the quantity of which varies according to the creativity and discretion of the ice cream maker.

Article 5 Preservation and sale of high quality artisanal ice cream. The durability of this premium product Made in Italy gastronomic is limited to 72 hours from its production. For the traceability of the product and the management of the allergens contained therein, the provisions of Regulations 178/2002 respectively apply.1 and 1169/20112.

Article 6: Sanctions. Unless the fact constitutes a crime, anyone who offers for sale or otherwise puts on the market high quality artisanal ice cream that does not comply with the provisions of the law is punished with a pecuniary administrative sanction from 1.600 to 9.500 euros.

The second bill

C. 4236 bears the following title: “Introduction of the denomination of 'traditional Italian artisan gelato' and provisions concerning its production”. The proposal was presented by D'Incà (M5S) and others, on January 18, 2017, announced on the following 20 and assigned on May 8 to the Agriculture Commission in the referent, with the opinions of the Constitutional Affairs, Justice, Budget, Activities Commissions Productive, Social Affairs, European Union Policies and the Bicameral Commission for Regional Issues.

In the introductory lecture he briefly traces the history of artisanal ice cream: the triumph of cold sweets, in particular sorbets, in the sixteenth century at the Florentine court of the Medici.

Also in Florence in the same period Bernardo Buontalenti presented his fabulous iced sweets, born from personal elaborations and certainly superior to those produced up to then.

These tasty desserts were based on eggnog and fruit, and had a great success, giving rise to the famous "Florentine cream" or "Buontalenti ice cream". The turning point of artisanal ice cream, that is to say its marketing, took place with Francesco Procopio dei Coltelli (1651-1727), who perfected the production of ice cream, adding two elements: cane sugar to sweeten it and salt in the ice that wraps the container to significantly lower the processing temperature.

Thanks to the same “Procope” our ice cream spreads in France. The report briefly mentions the expansion of ice cream in America, England and elsewhere; to the former ice cream sellers with carts, at the first automatic ice cream parlor in 1927 built by the Bolognese Otello Cattabriga.

The proposed law C. 4236 consists of three articles and an annex.

Article 1. Introduction and recognition of the denomination of "traditional Italian artisan ice cream". The denomination of traditional Italian artisanal ice cream is introduced, which distinguishes the artisan product obtained by respecting the indications contained in the production specification. The MiPAAF, in agreement with the MSE and the State-Regions Conference, will approve the recognition mark uniquely identify the product and the artisan businesses that produce it and distribute it to the public. The regional territorial bodies will establish and regulate the lists to which the artisan businesses themselves will be able to register and will define the procedures for the exercise of controls.

Article 2 Product promotion. The interested bodies (MSE, Regions) are required to encourage, with information campaigns aimed at retailers and consumers, the dissemination of traditional Italian artisanal ice cream, also by enhancing local recipes and food traditions that comply with the aforementioned specification.

Article 3. Sanctions. The unauthorized or improper use of the denomination and the identification mark constitutes an administrative food crime and is punished with a pecuniary administrative sanction from a minimum of € 250 to a maximum of € 10.000.

Attachment. Disciplinary for the production of traditional Italian artisanal ice cream. It is divided into two parts: 1) Raw material definition and requirements1; 2) Method of production and processing2.

Bruno Nobile

Note

1 Regulation (EC) n. 1334/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2008 relating to flavorings and certain food ingredients with flavoring properties intended for use in and on foods and amending Regulation (EEC) no. 1601/91 of the Council, regulations (EC) no. 2232/96 and (CE) n. 110/2008 and directive 2000/13 / EC.

2 Regulation (EC) n. 178/2002 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 January 2002, which establishes the general principles and requirements of food law, establishes the European Food Safety Authority and establishes procedures in the field of food safety. 

3 Regulation (EU) n. 1169/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2011 on the provision of information on food to consumers, amending regulations (EC) no. 1924/2006 and (EC) no. 1925/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council and repeals Commission Directive 87/250 / EEC, Council Directive 90/496 / EEC, Commission Directive 1999/10 / EC, Parliament Directive 2000/13 / EC European Union and of the Council, Directives 2002/67 / EC and 2008/5 / EC of the Commission and Regulation (EC) no. 608/2004 of the Commission.

4 The "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" is characterized by its use in the preparation of mixtures of ingredients from fresh and genuine raw materials, preferably of national origin. In the preparation of the product, the raw materials that enter the composition of the mixtures are mainly made up of milk and its derivatives, eggs, fruit and sugars.   

The "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" food is the optimal result of freezing and simultaneous stirring of a mixture of genuine, natural raw materials, preferably fresh, and high quality food ingredients, chosen, balanced and skilfully mixed by the artisan ice cream maker in his production laboratory according to his own originality and creativity.

  The artisan ice cream maker is the trained professional who has the necessary knowledge to produce "traditional Italian artisan ice cream".

  The "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" food is a fresh product ready for consumption that cannot be compared to frozen products as the negative temperature is an intrinsic characteristic of the product. The temperature necessary to maintain the structure makes the use of preservatives superfluous.

  Any product that maintains the structure and consistency of ice cream at a temperature above zero degrees centigrade cannot be considered "traditional Italian artisan ice cream".

      The characteristic consistency and softness of the product, which in this state is intended for sale and consumption, is obtained only by freezing, that is, by mixing and freezing the mixture at the same time.

  The "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" has its chosen land in Italy, where the artisan ice cream maker finds his ideal realization, especially in the use of ingredients typical of the territory.

    1. The "traditional Italian artisan ice cream", prepared with professionalism, according to logical principles and respecting the regulations in force, has important advantages: it is made with natural, fresh ingredients, offering optimal quality in terms of appearance, color and taste.

    2. The following is a non-exhaustive list of the main ingredients that are used:

          primary ingredients (which make up the main mass of the mixture) such as: fresh milk and / or its derivatives, cream, fats, eggs or egg products, sugars, water, fruit (generic) and / or its derivatives;

          secondary ingredients (which characterize the flavor), which are added to complete the mixture, such as: cocoa, chocolate, creams (pastes), possibly fresh fruit (or frozen and / or paste) and normally natural emulsifiers-stabilizers in a minimal functional quantity .

  Some ingredients, such as cream, eggs, fruit and water, are generally primary ingredients, but for particular tastes they also become secondary ingredients: cream for the fiordilatte, eggs for the egg cream, fruit for the sorbet.

  1.3 Low-fat milk powder can only be used as a source of proteins and sugars in order to integrate, balance and balance the content of solids. It cannot be used as a substitute for fresh raw material.

       1.4 In the preparation of "traditional Italian artisan ice cream", for the purpose of obtaining the finished product in different flavors and presentations, it is permitted to use finished food products that can be used for direct human consumption such as biscuits or their fragments, nougat, liqueurs, candied fruit and other products according to the creativity of the artisan ice cream maker.

      1.5 It is permitted to use natural additives in the preparation of mixtures and syrups and present in secondary ingredients, such as thickeners, emulsifiers, stabilizers, dyes and flavorings.

      1.6 In the preparation of the practice mixture, the exclusive use of milk and egg fats is allowed.

      1.7 The use of ingredients (primary, secondary, compound or finished) containing genetically modified organisms (GMOs) or their derivatives is prohibited.

  1.8 In traditional Italian artisanal gelato, ready for consumption, there must be no hydrogenated fats, artificial sweeteners, artificial additives and GMOs.

     1.9 Milk mixes:

              the mixtures for milk ice cream are characterized by a prevalent use of milk and derivatives and (where appropriate) eggs;

              the recipe must include the use of milk and its derivatives in a measure of not less than 65 percent by weight.

     1.10. Egg Cream Ice Cream:

          to be defined as such, in egg cream ice cream, the minimum percentage of egg yolk required in the recipe and used must be at least 6 percent by weight.

     1.11 Cream Ice Cream Ice Cream:

          to be defined as such, in cream ice cream the minimum percentage of milk fat provided in the recipe and used must be at least 8 percent by weight.

     1.12 Ice cream, fruit and / or vegetable sorbet:

              these types of ice cream are characterized by a high content of fruit and / or vegetables. Made with sugar syrup, milk and derivatives, it is defined as ice cream. If they are made with water or vegetable substitutes, it is declined as a sorbet;

              in the finished product the use of fresh (or frozen or paste) product must be guaranteed of at least:

                  15 percent by weight of lemon or lime juice;

                  20 percent by weight of pulp or juice of other citrus and tropical fruit;

                  30 percent by weight of pulp or juice of other fruit.

     1.13 Aromatic ice cream with herbs and / or roots and / or berries:

              this type is characterized by the content or only by the aromatic contribution of herbs and / or roots and / or aromatic berries in syrup or mixture.

5 In the preparation of the "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" the artisan ice cream maker prepares the mixture with quality raw materials, chosen directly and subsequently composed according to his own creativity. The artisan ice cream maker carries out the whole elaboration process (from the preparation of the mixes to the freezing). The "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" must be whipped according to a discontinuous process, manually intervening in the production process. Insufflation of compressed air or any other substance intended to artificially increase the volume of the product is not allowed.

2.1 The essential phases of the processing of "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" are briefly described in the following sequence:

a) selection and balancing of ingredients;

b) preparation of the mixture;

c) pasteurization (milk ice cream);

d) maturation (if any);

e) batch freezing of the mixture;

f) hardening (if any);

g) conservation of ice cream.

2.2 The mixture for "traditional Italian artisan ice cream" ready for freezing must have a minimum content of total solids (dry extract) of 35 percent for milk ice cream and creams and 30 percent for fruit sorbet .

2.3 In order to allow the carrying out of controls and verification of compliance requirements, the artisan ice cream maker adopts appropriate methodologies to identify and make traceable the raw materials and ingredients used in the preparation. In particular, the raw materials and ingredients used in the preparation are recorded.

2.4 The artisan ice cream maker directly carries out specific self-control activities in all phases of the manufacturing process to ensure product compliance and makes available the documentation and the laboratory facilities for the execution of external controls by and in the manner provided by the competent authorities.

2.5 Legislative references (not exhaustive):

2.5.1 traceability: Article 18 of Regulation (EC) No. 178/2002 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 January 2002 o Guidelines for the purposes of traceability of food and feed for public health purposes, pursuant to the agreement of 28 July 2005, published in the Official Journal no. 294 of December 19, 2005);

2.5.2 hygiene: regulation (EC) no. 178/2002 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 January 2002; regulations (EC) n. 852/2004, n. 853/2004, n. 854/2004 and n. 882/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004; Regulation (EC) No. 183/2005 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 January 2005 (obligation to apply written procedures based on the principles of risk analysis and critical control points - HACCP);

2.5.3 HACCP certificate: legislative decree 6 November 2007, n. 193;

2.5.4 labeling: regulation (EU) no. 1169/2011 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2011.



Translate »